Previous business/academic article
Academic Articles Awards > Economics

Buyer Resistance for Cartel versus Merger

Vikram Kumar, Robert C. Marshall, Leslie M. Marx, and Lily Samkharadze, International Journal of Industrial Organization 39, pp. 71-80, 2015

See Robert C. Marshall's resume See Leslie M. Marx's resume See Vikram Kumar's resume See Lily Samkharadze's resume

Procurement practices are affected by uncertainty regarding suppliers’ costs, the nature of competition among suppliers, and uncertainty regarding possible collusion among suppliers. Buyers dissatisfied with bids of incumbent suppliers can cancel their procurements and resolicit bids after qualifying additional suppliers. Recent cartel cases show that cartels devote considerable attention to avoiding such resistance from buyers. We show that in a procurement setting with the potential for buyer resistance, the payoff to firms from forming a cartel exceeds that from merging. Thus, firms considering a merger may have an incentive to collude instead. We discuss implications for antitrust and merger policy.

Download our brochure